By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Signalstar said:
Bamboleo said:
jammy2211 said:
I don't mean to be a troll, I'm just generally curious in your justification.

Why is it okay to have two different (Or in one case 3 :/) Pokemon games sales combined into one game, but not combine the same games sales on two different platforms?

If Modern Warfare 2 PS3 and Modern Warfare 2 360 are different games, so are Pokemon Blue and Pokemon Red :/.

I understand your point. Having all 3 pokemon games counted separately is the same as having Gears of War 2 and Gears of War 2 Special Edition counted differentely. It isn't that way and neither makes sense because it's the same game in the same platform with minor changes.

MW2 is the same game on both systems, but they're different systems and the list is about individual titles.

If you will, find a list of the most sold games mixing all platforms and all that and post here to discuss. Don't know if such a list is available though.

If that's the case what about Singstar Vol. 1-3 on the PS3 all the same games with a different set of songs. What about Dissidia Final Fantasy and Dissidia Final Fantasy Universal Tuning?

Singstar has entirely different content (songs) so it'd be different games.  Dissidia UT has identical content, only tweaked and added to, so it's the same game at it's core.

Where this gets tricky is more frequent iterative updates.  Street Fighter II for example, there's 5 distinct versions of it (SF2, SF2T/CE, SSF2, SSF2T, HSF2).  Or annual sports titles (which sometimes change dramatically, but sometimes barely change).