Really disappointed in Zelda Spirit Tracks...

[tolu619]

shams said:

sc94597 said:

Spirit Tracks is in my top 5 Zeldas, so you can already tell I disagree, I am to lazy to explain why I disagree though. :D I do have to say that you wouldn't be rating it a 7/10 if it wasn't a Zelda game though, would you?

The score is the score. The game isn't terrible - I'm still playing it. I'm just finding it disappointing.

For reference, my approx scores for some previous Zeldas (IMO):

PH: 9.5

Twilight: 9

OOT: 10

Wind Waker: 9.5

LTTP: 9.5

Zelda (original): 10 [hard to explain, but still my favourite in the series]

Zelda II: 9.5 [also really loved it at the time, as different as it was]

Majora's: 8.5 [really enjoyed it, but never finished it - and ultimately found it frustrating]

Awakening (GB): 9.5

Minish Cap: 9.5 [Brilliant game, unbelievable production for a GBA title]

...

I tend to rate Zelda games *very* highly. Hopefully ST will reach 8.5 or higher by the time I'm done with it.

I'll update this thread if/when my thoughts change...

NOOOOO!!!!Finish the game you must!It's my 2nd best game of all time(OoT) is my 1st.That's cuz it's the hardest 3d Zelda imo,and has by far the best side quests.If you beat the side quests in this game,ALL of them,the game becomes almost twice as good as if you had just beaten it normally.For me,OoT & MM are 10s!