Whats the best console for rpg gaming

[Euphoria14]

Barozi said:

Euphoria14 said:

I disagree. How can you for example declare that the 360 for example is the best console for RPGs when taste in RPGs vary?

 

Also how can you judge a game objectively? It is all subjective. This is why some great game are disliked and vise versa.

 

As for your last sentence I ask you this:

 

Is my opinion now wrong because I do not care for what critics think? Why are they the end all?

 

My opinion > Anyone else for me. End of story.

I am sure this is how many others feel as well.

 

Someone would need to be crazy if they expect someone to give and opinion like:

"I don't like any of the RPGs on that console but it is still better than the one that has the games I like."

 

Seriously? Just because critics say so? O_o

 

We may not come to an agreement here.

You're obsessed with the word "critics" or something ? I mentioned it one time and I even put it at the end of the sentence, because it was my intention to focus on the gamers.

and yeah my opinion > opinion of anybody else. But I say it again. It's not about you.

So: My opinion = meaningless in this case.

 

You said: "It is all subjective. This is why some great game are disliked and vise versa."

Now let's say I'd hate Demon's Souls and now someone makes up a thread asking if he should get Demon's Souls.

According to your logic I must say : "No it's a terrible RPG. Stay as far away from it as you can." (That would be my opinon)

Or I could say: "Well I didn't like it, but there were a lot of people liking it and it received many GOTY nominees. So there must be something in the game that caused fun, but unfortunately I didn't find it. So yeah why not, give it a try." (neutral view on the matter)

I mention critics because you say that people here have issues judging games objectively. How else would one judge something objectively unless there is a be all end all for what makes one game and/or system better then the rest?

 

Point is that there is no objective answer in this case. How can someone say DS is the best if they played no games for it and only have experience with PSP games? How can they say DS is the best if they did not like the games and they like the PSP games? You can't force anyone to vote on an answer that you or anyone else thinks is the defininitive answer. In the end there are no right answers, only opinions.

 

If you don't like Demon's Souls that is fine. I never said anything is wrong with that. There are plenty of people who dislike it.

 

I feel people should make votes based on personal experience, not vote on something if you know nothing about it. That to me is a blind vote and not someone speaking their mind but speaking from someone elses.