Silent Hill: Shattered Memories discussion thread *SPOILERS!*

[naiyo]

noname2200 said:

naiyo said:

not the highschool girl.  she was the mother.  thats what i took from it.

the whole highschool area... like the phone calls, the photos taking of the girl and principal in the car and others...

 

Michelle represents Cheryl's mother? I never considered that. What makes you think that?

As to the highschool itself, I'm fairly positive it meant that while she was in high-school she was having an affair with one of her teachers. Two of the three photos are thinly veiled references to that, as is the entire Pigtails line of messages. Speaking of, the Pigtails line was one of the more disturbing messages I got in the game.

Riachu said:

It could be true.  Ever watched Paranoia Agent?

 I've never even heard of it, to be honest. Is it a movie or TV show?

MaxwellGT2000 said:

Ok so apparently I got the love lost ending... which one is supposed to be the "good" ending again?

 That one.

morenoingrato said:
Ummm.... the sesion and harry weren't related, harry was a confused spirit looking for cheryl, cheryl was in terapist sesion in the lighthouse, so harry goes, mets her and the spirit shatters, cybil was real and existed there, but she was the one that discovered that harry was the spirit, lisa died for the pills, and dahlia dead was just an alucination

 This fits with some of the stuff, but not everything. For instance, why doesn't Doctor Kaufmann ever see Harry when the man bursts into a private therapy session? Also, Cheryl was never in the lighthouse: Lighthouse was just the name Kaufmann picked for his clinic. The place was just a standard office building, albeit with a searchlight on top.

Well when Michelle and her boyfriend was fighting in the car and Harry was sitting in the back seat looking at all of this... I thought thats how Cheryl might have seen her parents fighting once and a while.