Mafia Round 12 - Game Thread

[theRepublic]

Soleron said:
I think this should have been labelled an experiment in the OP. Something like, "the rules of this game may not be as expected; do not believe anything."

Interesting idea, but since no one figured it out (that everyone else was an even/odd day SK too) it was impossible to get useful; day discussion. Taking the emphasis away from day discussion made it a boring Mafia game, since only nights mattered.

I figured it out as I was thinking about who to kill on Night Two.  It doesn't matter though.  Even if everyone figured it out, there would still be no useful conversation to be had.  Everyone was just playing for themselves.

I agree that a game like this is much more interesting for the Mod than the players involved.  It became clear after Night One that days were pointless, and that pretty much killed discussion.