1. Dead Rising 2 (co op should be a blast)
2. Red Dead Redemption (I hope they keep the killer soundtrack filled with songs from Spaghetti Westerns)
3. Final Fantasy XIII (could easily be biggest disappointment also if I don't like the battle system or the story)
4. Max Payne 3 (loved the first two)
5. Bioshock 2 (The first Bioshock is one of a few FPS that I actually like)