Pachter : I'm TROUBLED by Lackluster Uncharted 2 SALES!

[libellule]

themanwithnoname said:

CGI-Quality said:

themanwithnoname said:
Ok, I fail to see how the fact that Gears of War doesn't count as a first party game means that we can write it off completely. Its sales are irrelevant just because Microsoft doesn't own the franchise or Epic? *is confused*

Point is, despite sales, it isn't owned by Microsoft. Can Sony claim MGS4?

Why not? First party in this discussion is really just a technicality anyway, is it not? MGS will always be associated with the PlayStation and Gears of War with the Xbox. I just don't see why that makes much of a difference in this discussion.

+1 for themanwithnoname

we should compare the 2 title

I enter and exit in this thread to say that :

Gears = solider + full badass + no brain shooter = very good sales

U2 : not solider + not as badass + not only brain shooter = good sales

MGS4 : a mix between those 2 games + brandname = very good sales