By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Fededx said:
I would have given the award to a 3rd party game this time, either Muramasa or Sillent Hill. As much as I love Mario and Luigi, they didn't deserve this award this time... This was a 3rd party year!!!

How didn't New Super Mario Bros Wii deserve this award (especially against a game like Muramasa)? 2D Mario is the pure definition of classic sidescrolling fun.