I have played both and Bathman shits all over Infamous.
I really don't feel like Killzone should be consider a contender simply for the graphic, its a polished game but I did not enjoy it even as much as Infamous.
ACII... have heard great thing about this and a friend of mine who's opinion I greatly respect gave this his GOTY but man I HATED the first game and find I do not have the incentive to purchase the sequal.
Uncharted is well deserved. Modern Warfare 2 is also a fairly polished game though I dislike it on a personal level.
@binary solo
Street Fighter 4 is an absolute gem of a game that did everything right, Its in my top 5 of this year and almost squeezed into my top 10 game of all time. Considering its excellent meta score and good popularity, I feel that it certainly does deserve a nomination spot, even on the PS3.
