Is NSMB Wii worthy of the title Game Of The Year?

[psrock]

Avinash_Tyagi said:

psrock said:

Avinash_Tyagi said:

psrock said:

Avinash_Tyagi said:

So a game has to be cinematic to be GOTY? Then that just shows another thing that is wrong with the industry

No, with so many games being released and being just terrific, a game needs to more than just " running, stoming and jumping, ect" to win GOTY, still a good game though.

  Except NSMB Wii is better than those other games, its gameplay is more refined, more engaging, and more fun, not to mention far more accessible.

 

All the other games like U2 have, is more cinematics, so what you're arguing, is that cinematics are more important than gameplay

I'M sure NSMB wii is better than the games you've never played.

You know what is great in 2009 : You can have a game with great gameplay, amazing cenematics all in one game.

Actually, those games have been available for years.

By that logic, a person needs to play every game to know whether it is good or not, so when was the last time you played the latest spongebob game or how about happy feet?  I don't need to play every game to know that NSMB Wii is the best.

I actually consider cinematic to detract from the game experience, I don't game to play movies I game to game.  Dialogue, cutscenes, and other cinematic stuff just pull a player away from the actual game.

You left out story.