Is NSMB Wii worthy of the title Game Of The Year?

[psrock]

Avinash_Tyagi said:

psrock said:

Avinash_Tyagi said:

psrock said:

Avinash_Tyagi said:

psrock said:

Avinash_Tyagi said:
^I knew you would feel that way psrock, but I know that if I don't find one thing interesting, and another thing very interesting, well then the game that is more interesting is the better game. I mean if I see a game and it doesn't look interesting, then why do I have to play it to know that I wouldn't like it?

I would actually give your opinion more importance if you had taken your friend's controller and at least try it. Don't  use your looking at friend play excuse to compare the games. It's really that good, little overhyped like NSWMB, but just a terrific game espacially if you like movies and comedy. And it's fun, which is very important to you, right.

 

Key problem right there, I don't really care for games to be like movies, I like games to be games, not movies

 

It's because until now, no games has been able to pull it off and Uncharted 2 did, beautifully too.

  See the whole concept of cinematic games doesn't appeal to me, one of the things that makes NSMB Wii so awesome, is it is arcade like, it doesn't try to be cinematic in the slightest, no cutscenes, no intricate plot, no excessive dialogue, just running, stoming, jumping, etc.

 

I agree with malstrom, games shouldn't try to be serious

Thus the reason it's not GOTY material.

So a game has to be cinematic to be GOTY? Then that just shows another thing that is wrong with the industry

No, with so many games being released and being just terrific, a game needs to more than just " running, stoming and jumping, ect" to win GOTY, still a good game though.