You're right- they don't deserve it. No game deserves a perfect score.
And as for them being against the Wii, well, that's true. Almost every Wii game gets a penalty for being on the Wii; the "justification" being that some game on the HD twins looks better. Conversely, to further smear the Wii, they'll also raise an HD score because it looks better than a Wii version does (or could, as they would say).
Personally, I don't care if a game has stickmen for graphics. If it's fun to play, that matters a lot more to me than a borefest that looks pretty. I'm not saying that the "perfect" games are the definition of boring, rather, graphics needs to not be the only thing they look at. Then again, they've bred the fanboy that way- feed them a pretty video and some pretty pictures, and watch them drool as they gobble it up. Makes doing the "reviewing" job much easier...
-dunno001
-On a quest for the truly perfect game; I don't think it exists...
