Judging by single player experience, Uncharted 2 > ... > ......... > .................................... > MW2. Well not really, but unlike Uncharted, Modern Warfare story seems to be built around mission ideas which don't connect too well to keep the story fluid and involving.
Both games have great OHMYGOD moments, yet Uncharted is still ahead (because of that incredible pacing). While playing Uncharted, I had problem putting the controller out of my hand and was glued to the screen, eager to try out what's comming next. In MW2, it felt like oh that was great, now another mission or should I go watch tv / wash dishes / take out garbage.
MW2 is a great game, highly polished, but it's lacking soul, feels like higly advanced lifeless construct. On the other hand Uncharted is like living organism that will slowly (yet quickly!) sucks you in and alienate you, you'll feel home.
IMO
/sarcasm warning
MY HYPE LIST: 1) Gran Turismo 5; 2) Civilization V; 3) Starcraft II; 4) The Last Guardian; 5) Metal Gear Solid: Rising
