eggs2see on 06 November 2009
| ioi said: Well we can get into a whole debate about how you review a game and what is important - I'll leave that to everyone else if you want to turn this thread into that. I'm simply saying that we don't have a "Nintendo bias" in our reviews, we strive for a particular balance which probably penalises poor presentation / graphics to a lesser extent that other sites. This can happen within a platform as well as across different platforms. |
Your 100% right, it's just my opinion and that is what i stated.
But what i am starting to believe now is that you have a Nintendo bias without even intentionally doing so. By putting more weight on elements that Nintendo developers also put more emphasis on you are unintentionally giving generous reviews to these games. Now this is just complete hypothesis, what is not is the review scores. So to shut gnizmo up ill think about getting a list of the scores and re-opening this thread with hard facts. That is unless of course you find the entire concept of the thread to be too anti VGChartz and would prefer i not do so. But i'm sure you don't have a problem with some criticism as long as it is not completely unfounded
