"Possibly, but I personally think it's pretty silly to put movies in the formula. You don't get more than 2-3 hours of entertainment out of them and, well, I buy my game consoles to play games on. If you want to watch movies, buy a movie player. Don't tell me I'm wrong here. Don't try to argue with me. That is simply how I think and I couldn't care less what you have to say (not saying you're going to say anything, I just hate the PS3 is also a movie player argument) and that's about that. "
I kinda sorta both agree and disagree with you here.
Yes, movies are much shorter than games (although the price to hours spent watching/playing them ratio can be similar for shorter games like HS).
Yes it would be rather silly to buy a gaming machine to watch movies only (except when it was the cheapest Blu-Ray player).
But if there are movies that you really want to watch in HD (because you think it will add to the experience like some people think that playing games in HD add to their gaming experience) why shouldn't they be counted in the formula?
They shouldn't be the main reason to buy it but they may push somebody slightly past the tipping point between buying one and not buying one.
And as you said that formula is personal so while watching HD movies might not be an incentive to buy a PS3 for you just like playing games from the current line up is not incentive enough for you they might be for someone else.
As for me, HD movie watching is a nice side benefit but it won't make me buy a PS3, nor will the current PS3 line-up at the current price/feature-set so I will be waiting for the price to drop and hoping that the 40GB flops so that Sony reintroduces BC in the PS3 (as per Phil Harrison's comment) so I can just wait for it to come down to a price that is good for me and hopefully they will introduce a EE+GS model in PAL territories (where I am) if the 40GB flopping makes them think BC is important or at least drastically improve the GS only PS3's BC.
So far it looks like I will buy a 60GB US model off off eBay in a few years and use some Action Replay like device to play my PAL PS2 games on it (but then I wonder if I will have problems with the 110v->240v current change between US and PAL).
"I do not suffer from insanity, I enjoy every minute of it"
