Half Life 2: Does it deserve it

[BenKenobi88]

kn said:
The Orange Box = $30 trade in at GS with a 30% extra trade (promo going on) +10% membership means I got $42 bucks for it. I got it at TRU 3:2 sale which means it cost me $40 plus tax. Considering I spent about $1.50 to play portal and learn that I don't like Half Life 2, I still give it a thumbs up, lol.

Interesting that my local GS already had a BUNCH of Orange box used -- like 10 already -- twice as many used Halo 3 and given the number of Halo 3 copies sold, there must be others like me out there that prefer the H3 experience over HL2.

 That's because the HL2 experience is gimped on 360, to be honest.

I'm not trying to be a PC fanboy...but the game is just designed for keyboard and mouse use...it does make a game different than a game designed for dual analogs, plain and simple.