let me be a little more elaborate about that last point. Games like metroid prime work without rails because in essence its not a shooter. jerk reactions are not required. its more like a point and click adventure game in the sense that you don't need to be very accurate and the game moves very slowly. Dead Space: Extraction is very fast paced, there is no way the controls would work, they are too inaccurate.
The Conduit was basically a rail shooter. It was endless hallways with enimies that barely moved. Its hardly a competent fps. You just push him along, but you never have any freedom of movement. Motion controls will restrict your game design when making a shooter until they are much more accurate.
Stop calling dead space extraction a bad job, the game is good. Its just as good as all the other shooters on the wii. Resident evil 4 being the only one thats better and even the re4 is a rail shooter with slow movement.







