Is Magna Carta 2 The Best JRPG Since Tales of Vesperia?

[Torillian]

selnor said:

Torillian said:
You are choosing what you like about D&D, not what defines it as a game. If your DM gave you character sheets and had you play through a largely linear story you would still be playing D&D.

That wasn't the point of a DM. You should know that if you know the game. The point of a DM is to tell you a story, give you scenarios. The choices were ALL up to you. The only things that would affect you not doing your choices were your attributes. Which represent real life limitations of your body. The system of numbers was placed in to represent carrying on or dying in the game. But the DM was NOT to choose the characters for you. You have full control over your character, and design.

Any DM who told you what you just said, would be kicked out of GamesWorkshop Tm Faster than you could say WTF?

Sigh fine, sadly I don't have enough D&D experince to counter all these points, but regardless of it not being acceptable by some, I still think that you'd be playing the game.

Regardless, all of these games are defined as RPG's, so your definition is meaningless.