My Supreme Viewpoint on the Big Three

[Torillian]

Avinash_Tyagi said:

Torillian said:

KungKras said:

Xxain said:

KungKras said:
^How many memorable?

what standards d you judge that by? KZ,LBP,Uncharted,Team ICO,J&D,R&C all seem memorable to me

I mean memorable as in, something to look back at and play and enjoy generations after they were new, like if you look at the 16-bit and 8-bt era, games that you will remember even to this day. Like Street Fighter II or Super Mario World. Tetris and PAC MAN are the ultimte examples, but those are in another league.

Out of those you mentioned, I'd say maybe the ICO games. LBP, sure that's one that will be remembered. And maybe Ratchet & Clank, maybe. Killzone2 may seem cool now, but my wild guess is that it will be remembered as just another FPS that happened to have really good graphics at the time. Same with inFAMOUS, just a Sandbox game that seemed cool at the time.

So what "memorable" games have Nintendo made this gen by your count?  And what in God's name are you basing "memorable" on?

Wii Fit, Wii sports, Mario Kart, NSMB DS, Nintendogs, Brain Age, Mario Kart both on DS and Wii, Brawl, Galaxy, just to name a few

So games are memorable based solely on sales?  All you've done is name the great games from Nintendo, want me to just do the same for Sony and then you can tell me how these don't have the magical property of being "memorable"

Honestly, it's like banging my head against a wall with "Nintendo rules" graffiti'd onto it.