Demon's Souls=First AAA JRPG This Gen?

[FreeTalkLive]

Torillian said:

FreeTalkLive said:

Torillian said:

FreeTalkLive said:
Maybe it is the eighth or ninth.

Three DQs on DS. The World Ends With You on DS. FF 4 on DS. Pokemon D/P/P on DS. Pokemon G/S on DS. BIS on DS. Some people think the FF on PSP also counts.

don't count remakes as part of this gen's games, and the other games you mentioned didn't recieve the necessary review scores, and you know that's what the thread is talking about.

 

 

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ds/marioandluigibowsersinsidestory

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ds/worldendswithyou

I didn't notice the abbreviation for M & L, but you're still wrong with World Ends with You.  So now it would be the 2nd if it got 90.  Not the 8th or 9th like you claimed.

Except I count remakes.  This is a wild guess, but I doubt I'll think any jrpg released this generation is as good as the DS version of FF 4 unless a DS version of FF 6 or a FF 7 remake comes out.  Although, I'm sure more gamers will end up thinking Pokemon P or some other Pokemon is the best game.