Uncharted 2 - the highest rated game ever?

[Torillian]

Feylic said:

leo-j said:
@Feylic

That isn't true with every game, MGS4 has a 94, and people think its underrated..

O, well that's good. Maybe there is some numerical cut off where a game is under/overrated.. 94.7%?!

nah, lots of people talk about MGS4 being overrated, just like any high scoring game.  GTAIV gets it the worst because it got such insanely high scores while having obvious flaws that make those scores hard to justify in hindsight, but every high scoring game has a fair share of detractors.