Is Silent Hill: Shattered Memories looking better than SH: Homecoming?

[theARTIST0017]

gera4390 said:

homecoming looks better than shatter memories, I liked the game , the story kinda sucked but it was an ok story.
and Homecoming has a great atmosphere I wish there were more games like homecoming or dead space talking about atmosphere, Homecoming is so underrated though.

Btw the last stage was the hostel movie.

That movie is very disturbing. I think Shattered Memories will turn out to be a better game than Homecoming though, even though you can't fight anything in it. If only it was a Wii exclusive. Why does it have to be shared with the PS2?