Good luck, I hope you guys get review copies, those are always fun. Beyond that just try to look at a game objectively and then be true to yourself about how each component works together. Objectively you may see that a game suffers from framerate issues, but it's your decision how much this affected the overall experience of the game. Also I would reconsider the term replay value since some games are not designed around that ideal but instead just giving you a great experience once for as long as possible (JRPG's in particular)
...









