Do any of the Halo games deserve the popularity and critical acclaim?

[Vetteman94]

Crashdown77 said:

Vetteman94 said:
It deserves it when its a good game.
Halo: CE was a brilliant FPS, one of the best I have ever played at that time.
Halo 2 was also a very good game but it seemed they took a step back on the story to focus on MP, not something I would've done but still very good game.
Halo 3 was kind of a let down because they took another step back in the story department to focus on the MP. The graphics were sub-par but the brilliant controls were still there, I never got into the MP mainly because I had my PS3. And it shouldnt always be about the MP, if thats the case just cut out the story mode and focus on MP.
Halo Wars, from what little I have played of it was alot of fun. It actually made RTS games on a console fun to play.
This is all my opinion

I just want to say for someone with almost 900 trophies (meaning you probably spend a lot of time on your PS3) and with a fairly anit-360 signature, you have some really fair posts almost all the time. Kudos to you sir!

Thank you, I guess, but what is so anti-360 about my sig?  I even mention my 360 in my sig!!!!!  And I have a pic of it in my profile, but not one of my PS3.    If its the comment about the exclusive games then it goes both ways for PS3 and 360 owners.