twesterm on 24 October 2007
If this were any other year I would agree that Halo 3 would get it but there are just too many great games this year. Has any other year ever seen so many games with so many 9+ ratings? I don't think Halo 3 or MP3 will even be in most of the runnings this year which is sad because they are both really good games.
-edit-
My personal prediction for the top 3 games to be on the most GotY lists are Bioshock, Super Mario Galaxy, and Mass Effect. Mass Effect is still a little iffy to me but if it turns out to be everything it's supposed to be I think it will make it on quite a few GotY lists.
