Well, the argument isn't really that it won't have hardcore games, just that it won't have enough of them to satisfy a "real" hardcore gamer, who allegedly spends hours upon hours playing games each week and thus churns through a lot of games buying a dozen or more each year. Personally I haven't found that volume of games that I'd want on 360/PS3, so most players of that caliber would probably be getting more than one console anyway.