Most overated game of all time.

[Torillian]

Game which has reviews higher than I think it should....hmmm....

I think one obvious contender for me would be Fallout 3, a game with that many obvious technical flaws shouldn't get 90 on meta in my mind. It didn't do enough to make up for those.

GTAIV is another contender for the exact same reason, shouldn't be as high as it is. I don't know why it seems the reviewing community as a whole decides to give a free pass to some games.