Just finished Shadow of the Colossus!

[Reasonable]

Christhor said:

Reasonable said:

Christhor said:
TBH I didn't really find the ending all that sad, it might've been because I played Ico first and IMO that ending was much sadder. Overall I still thought SotC was the better game.

Did you wait through the credits to play out the final scene with Ico?

Of course I did, I always sit through the credits :)

without spoiling to much I even did the watermelon thing on my second play through.

Yah, so in the end it's not so sad really, is it?  I found SOTC to be clearly the more melancholy game, with a sombre mood throughout that built to a very moving finish.

Ico felt more like the slow advancement into sunlight, coming to an essentially uplifting ending.