4 Way tie (Not kidding)
MechWarrior 4 Mercenaries
Final Fantasy Tactics
The Legend of Zelda A Link to the Past
Super Mario World
they are all incredible games that I have replayed more times than I can count, and the kicker is they are all from different genres and wildly different games. I will admit that my love for each of these games is a mix of nostalgia and love of the series/subject matter but each and every time I replay these games I enjoy them like the first time even though I have each of them thoroughly memorized - that is the tell of a truly good game to me.
Currently dreaming of: DKC4 or Sonic the Hedgehog 4 (classic 2D platformers) for WiiWare, Smash Bros. for DSi, New Super Mario World for DSi, a Wii remake or true sequel of Final Fantasy Tactics.
One down, hopefully more awesomeness to come.
