Dual Analog Vs. IR controls

[silentmac]

--OkeyDokey-- said:

silentmac said:

Sorry double post...

The best Wii games don't even use motion control in any significant way, though. Galaxy, Brawl and Zelda I mean. Unless the controls are completely broken they don't add or detract from the overall experience at all, really.

Edit: quoted the wrong the post >_>

True but beside first party exclusives, is the biggest reason for owning a Wii not controls?  I could play Little Big Planet/R&C, Street Fighter 4, and Shadow of the Colossus and get a similar experience on PS2/PS3...

Also, do you think certain genres benefit more than others?  I specifically said Galaxy (platformers), Brawl (fighters), and Zelda (action/adventure) don't benefit that much from motion or IR in my opinion in the top post (although this could change with WM+, especially Zelda).  What about FPS, TPS, RTS, Team Sports, Individual Sports, Racing, Brawlers, point and click etc.  If those genres do benefit, is it just from a fun factor (superficial) standpoint or do you think there is there a technical benefit for competitive play?