disgaea3:abstence of justice or valkyria chronicles ?

[Euphoria14]

I own both titles and I loved Valkyria Chronicles. The story was pretty good and the combat was fun and felt fresh.

So I will have to go with Disgaea 3.

Come on! What other game will allow you to witness a character manage to place a gigantic egg dish on top of another character's head without him noticing?

I love games that have 2D sprites too, so my answer is a tad bit biased.