Well this is their conclusions from UDF:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gamespot:
Incredible production values and plenty of thrilling moments help make Uncharted an action-packed adventure, in spite of some slightly uneven gameplay.
The Good
- Lush jungle environments are stunningly realized
- Drake's animations are nuanced and naturalistic.
The Bad
- Tough and plentiful enemies can make firefights frustrating
- Platforming elements can be too forgiving
- Certain story elements are underdeveloped.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IGN:
Closing Comments
Here's the thing about Uncharted, the final sum is far greater than the individual parts. Maybe you don't dig the combat or maybe the pop-in gets you down, but the overall package of an endearing story, outstanding score, great performances and fun gameplay should put this title on the top of your holiday wishlist. Say what you will about the PS3, but Uncharted isn't just a standout for Sony -- it's a standout for gaming as a whole.
| Rating | Description |  |
|---|---|---|
| out of 10 | click here for ratings guide |
|
| 9.5 | Presentation The whole thing has the polish of a major motion picture and goes out of its way to immerse you in the experience with amazing cutscenes, music and more. |
|
| 9.0 | Graphics There's no doubt the game looks great and that the use of in-game assets for the movies is seamless transition, but there's still a fair amount of screen tearing and texture pop in. |
|
| 9.5 | Sound From the low instrumental piece accompanying the opening screen to the sweeping score that runs throughout the whole game, this is what videogame music should be. |
|
| 9.0 | Gameplay This game is flat-out fun to play. Leaping from ledges is awesome, shootouts are fun, and the occasional vehicle section is a nice change of pace. Still, the pirate battles can be a bit much. |
|
| 8.5 | Lasting Appeal The game is short, but the medals, rewards and bonuses should be enough to bring you back at least once. |
|
| 9.1 |
OVERALL (out of 10 / not an average) |
 |
