dbot said:
HappySqurriel said:
dbot said:
I am having trouble following your logic. The graphics of a DS game should be compared with other games on handheld platforms, the graphics of a current generation console game should be compared with other games available on current generation consoles, and pc games should be compared to other games offered on pcs.
|
What makes it fair to consider a different game on the PS3/XBox 360 when you look at a Wii game, but it isn't fair to consider the same game on the PC when you look at a PS3/XBox 360 game? The only thing that justifies protecting the HD consoles from the PC is that the PC is more expensive and has a different control set-up ... Wait a minute, weren't the HD consoles (basically) twice the price of the Wii at launch and don't they have a different control method?
|
So I guess you support my statement that all reviews should include the phrase "for a Wii game." Maybe reviewers should grade the Wii graphics on a PS2/original Xbox scale.
Maybe we should include PC sales in the console gaming charts?
|
Why on earth would you need to put "For a Wii game" in a review? Do we need to put "For a HD console game" next to any comments on controls in those games?
People who are reading the review know its a Wii game so they are fully aware of its limitations, and all statements will already be understood in the context that it is a Wii game.
