| JPL78 said: twestern, well I respect your opinion and agree in part but I think you need to realize "it's a bad game" is an opinion. Several people, including me like it a lot. That doesn't mean we are noobs or haven't played since 1995, it just means we accept it for what it is. Super streamlined arcade-like magic that doesn't cost an arm and a leg to play competitively.
edit: also magic was always based in luck of the draw. But its not all luck, even in this version. You still have to know the strategies to win. If you make mistakes you will lose. You have to know what to bring out when, what to enchant, when to attack, when not to attack, when to defend, how much mana to leave open in case you need it, etc. etc. It will always involve luck but even in a simplistic version of the game like this you have to actually know how to play and not make mistakes. |
All cards game are based on luck. Yes deck construction help but it's still luck. I don't know why everyone is so hang up on this deck construction aspect of Magic. What going to happen you will always have that meta game decks will always be the same you will just get a few competive deck. ie all decks will be the same .. that's what happen in all card games you will have one or two deck that are dominating and everyone will make the same decks.
