With 2 types of controls, its hard to find a reviewer who doesn't have a preference. If review by a traditionalist, then the motion controls are cause for a lower score.
In this case it seems that the control lowered the score by .2 by an apparently traditionalist.
The HD version got +.2 because of its realistic portrayal (in other words better graphics).
"¿Por qué justo a mí tenía que tocarme ser yo?"