if Nintendo had shown Natal instead...

[Untamoi]

ironman said:

dark_gh0st_b0y said:
i think Natal is very limited, and if was announced by Nintendo most people would see it as another family game/concept

i don't understand how Natal possibilities are endless, what exactly can you play with it!?
ok, there are some great things like on-rails shooter with fighting elements would rule : P a swordplay, a fitness game, sports games and party games

sports games like running won't be favored by Natal, so Wii has sports as well, fitness is ok i guess i a bit favored by Natal, a swordplay game is just limited to sword or karate, nothing more, you can't even walk, it will be cool but will get boring pretty fast

what are the other possibilities, it does not even have one button, do you realize what that means, you can't do a lot of things, not even move character

let's think of the best games, Halo could work with Natal, how?
a fighter like street fighter or ssbb would work? Mario Kart, how are going to throw shells and stuff, Mario Galaxy, Assasin's Creed, any RPG?? i think it's very limited for gamers at least

i see that Natal is great, but i cannot understand why most core-gamers like it, from the point they hated Wii remote and WM+ i don't see how you can be impressed by this when is mostly sports and party games (which is what MS wants, casuals), and this is why you hate Wii, , and now you support this because it's not Nintendo.... : (

Wow, really? When did I ever say I hated the Wii? Did I not say that I thought their Wiimote was innovative and cool when it first came out? Did I not say that if MS created the Wiimote+ I would be very unimpressed. Did I not also say that if Nintendo came out with NATAL I would have been just as impressed with it? You sir, owe me an apology. I do not hate the Wii, It just isn't my cup of tea. Just because you hate anything MS (and it shows greatly) Does not mean that anybody who does not own your precious console is automatically a hater. Try reading my damn posts, I have answered EVERY SINGLE QUESTIOn you have asked. But since you seem unable to fully comprehend what you see on your screen. Let me reiterate. (read it slowly and let it sink in before you decide to post more bullshit)

Buttons: you don't need buttons. If you want to jump in the game, just jump in real life, you wanna reload, make the motion that you are reloading your weapon in real life, you wanna change weapons, just tell NATAL which weapon you want.

MS has said that they plan to make Halo and COD playable on NATAL. 

You obviously cannot comprehend how NATAL can and will work with games of all types, therefore, I expect I will have to post all this a third time, just like I had to do in the two other threads. You people can be dense sometimes. Now, NEVER, EVER, EVER, accuse me of hating a console again, do you understand?

Playing an FPS and other action games without controller would make playing very tiresome. If you would have jump every time your character or run in place if you want to move then most people couldn't play game more than 5-10 minutes at a time. Playing even 1 hour at a time would require extremely good fitness. In some platformers you would have to jump almost constantly so those games would simply not work very well with Natal alone. And fighting games would be very difficult (if not impossible) if you would have to do every move physically. Even if Natal would be very sensitive it would still be tiresome to play these games with it. In combination with controller Natal would work well with FPS and some other games but not alone. Well, unless you want to exercise every time you play games.

Constantly shouting commands doesn't sound very good either. Voice recognition has its problems and it doesn't always recognise commands. There is no voice recognition which would always recognise what you say. And voice recognition doesn't work very well in many languages. Voice recognition is good for english-speaking persons but in most other languages voice recognition it is just terrible. My native language is not english so I wouldn't want voice recognition because most games are not even translated here.

And with Natal there is also an issue with limited space. Most living rooms have only limited space so it would difficult to use.

Then again, perhaps upcoming games prove me wrong. There is still a possibility that MS knows how to make even action games to work with Natal. Nobody has used Natal so we can't know how it works in reality. And without good games Natal would be worthless anyway.