I'm going to go with a tie.
I would have given it to MS and Ninty, BUT despite Sony having a really disappointing (for me) megaton of FF14 Online, they did exactly what I wanted them to:
no talk of sales numbers and throw a haymaker from the start (they did that, uncharted 2). I have to recognise that.
Each of the 3 had a really big down point: Nintendo with the casual bit about the mystery book on ds and fashion games, MS with Joyride and Sony with spending too much time showing very little of their take on motion controls
But all three recovered ridiculously well after that.







