Which is the better game, RE:4 or RE:5?

[RVDondaPC]

Ari_Gold said:

KylieDog said:
RE5 beats RE4 through its mercenary mode alone, never mind the main game, co-op or verses, all of which also beat RE4 in every way..

quoted for truth. Mercenary mode provides so much replay value, i can't believe its a mini-game

His time is limited. I don't think he cares much about replay value.

RE5 has a pretty terrible single player/co-op storyline.  It was as if a 14 year old was in charge of making the game. The gameplay itself is pretty fun but there is no real sense of engrossment because of many of the decisions the game developers chose in order to make the game more casual friendly. RE4 on the other hand is the epitomy of an engrossing game.