I replayed them both recently. Both still fantastic. Both still probably my favorite console games.
Ico still edges SOTC for story/characters IMHO but SOTC always feels much more epic in scope if not as involving in terms of characters (not a surprise given the way the characters are set up).
Ico is like a great little fairy tale while SOTC feels more like an old myth.
Here's to Trico Project - my only first day, no questions asked title this generation.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...







