Who here thinks that CGI-Quality would make an awesome Mod?

[starcraft]

Kantor said:

seece said:

starcraft said:

Million said:

Kynes said:

starcraft said:
CGI is what could be described as an ardent fan, or a mature fanboy.

He makes large attempts to control any anti-Microsoft tendencies in his opinions, and too tone down pro-Sony thoughts into the realm of actual possibility. I actually find this to be refreshing and genuine, so he shouldn't take this as an insult at all.

That said, the occasional moments when he oversteps the bounds of those self-imposed structures are largely inconsequential as an ordinary poster. But as a mod, such moments could be quite destructive.

So while I hope CGI will continue to be the entertaining and constructive poster he has become, no, he should not be a mod.

This is the reason why CGI shouldn't be a mod, too fan/biased to Sony to be a "respected" mod. All his decisions would be scrutinized, trying to find traces of fanboyism, and could bring problems. He is, as this thread shows, a very respected poster, bringing maturity and well thought reasonings to the "Sony movement", but as a mod I think it wouldn't work.

Well some people might argue Twestern was exactly the same , he frequently posts contraversial PS3 content . I don't think CGI is like that but even if he was we need an opposite force for some balance.

Fortunately, we already have them:

http://vgchartz.com/profiles/profile.php?id=4794

http://vgchartz.com/profiles/profile.php?id=4285

http://vgchartz.com/profiles/profile.php?id=15711

 

 

http://vgchartz.com/profiles/profile.php?id=5692

 

as well.

I think thats enough!

Sqrl is a PS3 fan?

News to me. Seeing as he doesn't own a PS3. I have to agree, though, that despite the mods having their own biases, it's more or less equal between them. And they all do a really good job of keeping those biases in check.

We could do with another pro-Sony mod, but...these things are not for us to decide.

When we have long-time site members actually leaving because it is starting to be overrun by PS3 fanboys, what possible justification can you offer for another pro-Sony mod before a Pro-Nintendo or Pro-Microsoft one?