VGC Top 100 Discussion thread

[Majin-Tenshinhan]

Derek said:

Majin-Tenshinhan said:
Actually, considering most Mario Kart-games are really great, you shouldn't go "Well they should only have one, otherwise it's unfair" ... Because a good game is a good game. This is the list of Top 100 best games. Discrimination like "Well we already have a game from this series, so we shouldn't include this game even if it's loads better than lots of the others on the list" would piss me off a lot more than what I'm seeing now.

 

 Some people think the Madden games are really great, too.  However, the gameplay changes to Mario Kart are of the same depth that happens in the Madden games.  When things change too much, people bitched (see: Double Dash).

This isn't discrimination.  This is intelligence.  Most of the Mario Kart games are EXACTLY the same.  Besides, Mario Kart 64 FTW.

Different games are different games. Arguments could be made to many other games being EXACTLY the same besides perhaps the story.

I agree that Mario Kart 64 is the best, though. Really, though, they are games. Different games. And they should be judged as such.