Wiimote 8/10 After spending about 30 hours playing shooters on the Wii were you can aim freely with the Wiimote I can say this is the best. With time and experience, I can easily get repeated head shots even in crazy environments. I can't say that about analog stick(not even with heavy auto aim) While I like the aiming with the Wiimote better it's looking around that's a problem. since the Wiimote is not a on a stable surface, one flick of the wrist and your all over the place. So I'm sure newer titles will fix this. really it's hard to compare the brand new Wiimote with all lackluster fps titles against the other two that have had more then a decade of great shooters to compare.
Mouse 8/10 Yes I rank it tied with the Wiimote, and while as pointed out above it's easier for movment it's simply more natural to point with your arm/hand at what you want to shoot, so it losses points two points in that respect.
Analog Stick/game pad 4/10 : I hate this setup, and only play along with heavy auto aim. But the fact that most Wii shooters don't use auto aim, and the analog sticks mostly do is simple admission to the lack of control with analog sticks. The prescision simply isn't there. and this setup has led me to not purchasing many games because of it. Like the fact that I'm debating on whether or not to buy Halo 3 simply because of this, yet if Halo 3 were on the wii I'd have preordered it already.
