PS3 has a higher attach rate than Xbox 360?

[Pristine20]

nightsurge said:

ruimartiniman said:

Sony’s Peter Dille has claimed that PS3 has a higher attach rate than Xbox 360, Gamasutra reports.

“If you factor in Xbox 360’s longer time in the marketplace and larger install base, Xbox 360 should be selling twice as many software units as PS3 if attach rates were equal — and that is just not what we are seeing at retail with many multiplatform titles,” he said.

Here are the figures:

• Street Fighter IV: Only 44,000 units separate the two consoles, with Microsoft winning by a 1:1 ratio. Yet the Sony version sold 402,919 units giving it an attach rate of 5.5 percent compared to Microsoft’s 446,435 units with a 3.1 percent attach rate.

• Tomb Raider: Underworld sold 136,245 units on PS3, with an attach rate of 1.9 percent. The Xbox 360 version sold 108,784 units, giving an attach rate of 0.7 percent.

• Prince of Persia: Microsoft outsold Sony by 36,000 units giving the title a attach rate of 2.1 percent for the console compared to 3.7 percent on PS3.

• GTA IV: Had a 26.9 percent attach rate on PS3 versus Xbox 360’s 23 percent, but there was a staggering sales gap between the machines: 3,362,196 360 units were sold compared to 1,959,798 units for PS3.

 

Wow.... I didn't realize there were so many cherries to be picked that could make the PS3 look like it has a higher attach rate

So let me understand this.  2x the console means that EVERY game has to sell 2x as much on that larger install base?  What a stupid thing to think.  He gives 4 examples.  4.  What about all the rest that sell 2x as much if not more?  And what about the overall attach rate being like 3-4 points higher on 360 than PS3?

Why is it that PR guys are always the biggest fanboys with the worst logic?

 

I'd like to know what "the rest" are. M$ attach ratio argument has always used total software sales which seems like the greater crime of cherry-picking IMO. You can only use multiplat games to determine attach ratios.

The whole attach rato argument is pretty useless anyway so I don't even know why M$ decided to add it to their sales pitch in the first place