LEGEND OF ZELDA PHG REVIEWED!

[tabsina]

naznatips said:

Computer & Video Games UK		7/4/2007	10 out of 10	100.0%
Game Informer		10/1/2007	9.5 out of 10	95.0%
NGamer UK		9/1/2007	95 out of 100	95.0%
Games Master UK		9/1/2007	94 out of 100	94.0%
IGN		9/25/2007	9 out of 10	90.0%
Edge Magazine UK		9/1/2007	9 out of 10	90.0%
gamesTM		9/1/2007	9 out of 10	90.0%
Eurogamer		8/14/2007	9 out of 10	90.0%
Play Magazine		10/1/2007	8 out of 10	80.0%
RPGamer		8/30/2007	4 out of 5	80.

f we want to see how stupid this makes them look:

Sonic the Hedgehog industry average 4.3
Play Magazine review 9.0
Difference: +4.7

Lair industry average 5.8
Play Magazine review 10
Difference: +4.2

Heavenly Sword industry average 8.1
Play Magazine review 10
Difference: +1.1

Phantom Hourglass average score 9.1
Play Magazine review 8.0
Difference: -1.1

These guys are all over the place. I think the SDF has more accurate reviews than Play Magazine.

That doesn't seem like much in terms of out of 10, but when you think about it in terms of
+47%
+42%
+11%
-11%

it makes it much more evident that something weird is going on

I was actually under the impression that Play Magazine was a solely PS magazine until i saw that they had a score for PH on it