Of these two, I'd pick SMW. It's slicker, feels faster and more responsive. And I loved the secret exits.
SMB3 was a fantastic game as well, but going back, I enjoy SMW more - it's more timeless, in my opinion.
My favourite Mario game... that's too hard to decide.
SMB1 started it all for me, its the essence of what makes a Mario game. I loved SMB2 for its strange atmosphere, might just be one of my favourites. Sunshine was almost as good as Mario64, only the "tropical island" theme got a bit boring towards the end. Galaxy absolutely overwhelmed me with its creativity.
I think I'll say Mario Galaxy & Yoshi's Island.
Currently playing: NSMB (Wii)







