Brawl vs. Halo 3, Predictions

[Legend11]

RolStoppable said:

naznatips said:
I'm with the majority here, Halo 3 initially, Brawl in the long run. I'd even go so far as to say in lifetime sales all of these Wii games will outsell Halo 3:

Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Super Mario Galaxy
Mario Kart Wii

Woah there, you are really taking a big risk by saying these three games will outsell Halo 3. If you just think about it for a few seconds, you will realize that the chances of these games to outsell Halo 3 are realistically only about 99.99 %.

@MontanaHatchet

Smash Bros. is incredibly strong in Japan, both games had attach rates of about 35 % on both, N64 and GC. Melee was also the only million seller the GC had in Japan. 

I really have to question the people who're making outrageous claims because of the Wii's success.  Halo 2 outsold the best selling Brawl game (so far) by almost 2 million of copies, the Halo series has shown that it has longer legs than the Brawl series, and at least some of the Wii's success (I say a lot actually) can be attributed to Wii Sports, a casual game in which I can't see a large part of it's audience attracted to Brawl.  Yet the people here are making predictions that go against everything we know about the previous games in both series.  I think the Wii's success is going to some peoples' heads.