And the winner is ==> Metroid Prime 3 !!!

[miasma23]

Both of these games are great, but as a whole, having played both, Mp3 deserves a win, though i doubt it will get it. The problem is forsee is Nintendo marketing the wii to the casual gamer as opposed to the 360 for the hardcore. Even when you take into account the 10 million wii owners out there, most of them seem to be more interested in WiiSports than an FPS, while the 10 million 360 owners are all gonna want to play Bioshock. I hope I am wrong, it would be real nice to see these "casual gamers" try a real game, and I would love for there first one to be a Metroid.