By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

I would most certainly pick Mass Effect over Bioshock. While I think Bioshock was an excellent game, Mass Effect was much more engaging in my opinion.

However, Mass Effect isn't much of an FPS. For that matter, I didn't really think Bioshock was that great of an FPS. A great overall game (which is the most important), just not a great FPS.