Heavenly Sword gets good review from 1up

[carlos710]

grandmaster192 said:

shams said:
I can't understand how this is an 8 and MP3 a 9 - for the same reviewer. Doesn't make any sense to me at all.

That said, IMO HS is a 7/10 game - so I can understand why it gets reviews in the 6/10...8/10 range.

I don't understand it neither, considering that Heavenly Sword blows Metroid Prime 3 away in terms of gameplay, story, and visuals. Metroid scoring higher then Heavenly is bull, and tells me that it's only getting a high score because it's one of Nintendo's major franchises. In my opinion, Heavenly Sword is a 8.7 game, with Metriod being a 8.1 game.

 

For me heavenly sword is an 0/10 game -i just never would spend 60$ for 6 hours of bad gameplay with no replay value at all.

We should compare heavenly sword with WiiPlay, or Alien syndrome, games of that quality, not with metroid prime 3.