This year was even more BS than last year. Having played and enjoyed both, Soul Calibur IV is not even in the same league as Brawl. Brawl should have won, hands down.
And don't even get me started on GTAIV--it holds the distinction of being the only nominated game that didn't deserve a nomination. My friend and I weren't even considering it when we were debating over what the winner would be.
I must say, the best part was the beginning with the console sex ("You play the same games!"--gets shot by Wii).
Count me out for watching next year.